Where does our data come from?
Our data comes from official sources, the broker's own documents and the regulators' registers. For every broker we collect 378 data points, such as licenses, costs, leverage and protections, and we collect them for each company of the broker's group, because each company has its own license and its own conditions. We check every value against the rules of each country and record the date we checked it.
- The broker's own documents, such as its website, its terms, its fee schedules and its key information documents.
- The registers of financial regulators, such as the FCA in the United Kingdom, CySEC in Cyprus and ASIC in Australia.
- The rules of each country on who can open an account with a foreign company, and with which leverage.
Which company of the broker's group serves your country?
A broker is often a group of companies, each licensed in a different place. The company that opens your account depends on the country where you live, and it decides your regulator, your protections and your maximum leverage.
- If you live in the United KingdomPepperstone Limited
- If you live in GermanyPepperstone GmbH
- If you live in AustraliaPepperstone Group Limited
You can check which company serves your country for any broker, at the top of our home page and in every review. When no company of the group accepts people who live in your country, we say so, and in the best broker lists of your edition the broker has no button to open an account.
How is the score calculated?
Every broker gets a score out of 100 for each company of its group. A formula calculates the score from the data, and nobody at InvestinGoal can change it by hand. When the data changes, the score changes with it.
The formula looks at 12 areas. Eleven have a weight, shown in the table, and the twelfth, Trading quality, shows the overall score. A broker that offers both CFDs and real stocks can have two scores, one for each. Forex lists and reviews show the CFD score, and stock lists show the stock score.
| Area | Weight |
|---|---|
| Whether your money is safe, and whether the broker teaches: 43% | |
| Regulation | 16% |
| Safety | 15% |
| Learn trading | 12% |
| What you use on every trade: 42% | |
| Cost | 10% |
| Mobile trading | 9% |
| Available markets | 8% |
| Trading platforms | 8% |
| Trading conditions | 7% |
| The service around your account: 15% | |
| Customer care | 6% |
| Account opening | 5% |
| Account types | 4% |
Why these weights. Regulation and safety weigh most because they tell you whether your money is safe, and learning weighs more than most because we start from beginners. Customer care, account opening and account types weigh least because they describe the service around your account, not the risk you take.
What does each area measure?
These are the 12 areas of every review, with what each one looks at.
- Regulation
- The licenses of the company that serves you. We sort 62 regulators into three tiers, and a license from a top-tier regulator, such as the FCA, ASIC or a regulator in the European Union, counts most.
- Safety
- How your money is protected, such as client money kept apart from the company's own and an investor compensation scheme, with the years the company has been in business and the security of your login.
- Available markets
- What you can trade or invest in, such as CFDs, real stocks and ETFs, futures and options.
- Cost
- What you pay to trade on a standard account, such as spreads and commissions, measured against a benchmark for each market, and the fees you pay outside trading.
- Trading quality
- The overall answer to whether the broker is good for trading. It shows the total score, and in our reviews it brings together the results of our tests.
- Trading conditions
- The tools that help you manage risk on each order, and support for automated trading, such as Expert Advisors.
- Account types
- The accounts you can choose, such as ECN and raw spread accounts, copy trading and an unlimited demo account.
- Account opening
- How you open and fund an account, such as the currencies of the account and the payment methods.
- Trading platforms
- The trading platforms you can use, such as MetaTrader, cTrader, TradingView or the broker's own, and what they let you do.
- Mobile trading
- The apps you can trade with, the broker's own and the MetaTrader apps.
- Learn trading
- What the broker teaches, such as courses, guides, webinars and a demo account to practice.
- Customer care
- How you can reach the broker, in how many languages and through which channels, and whether you get a dedicated manager, priority support or a callback.
How do we test brokers?
For our reviews we open accounts and use them. We test every broker at its European company, because what we measure, the quality of trading, changes little from one company of the group to another, while the services of each company come from our database.
- Spreads on eight instruments, from EUR/USD to gold and Bitcoin, at the London and New York openings, for three days.
- Spreads during a news release, to see how high they go and when.
- Commissions on a real order on the account with commission.
- Overnight fees on EUR/USD, buying and selling, on a normal night and on a Wednesday.
- Execution of ten market orders, with the price asked, the price filled and the time in milliseconds.
- Withdrawals by bank transfer, from the request to the money in the bank, with the costs.
- Live chat with three questions, timing the first answer from a person and checking whether the answer is right.
Each review says what we tested, with which company and accounts, and when, including when we used only a demo account.
How are our best broker lists ordered?
A best broker list can also include brokers that don't accept people who live in the country of its edition: their card says so. The order combines the score with our preference, based on the brokers we know best and trust most.
How do we keep the data up to date?
Every value in our database carries the date we last checked it, and our reviews show that date. When a broker changes its conditions, we update the data, and the score changes on every page that shows it.
Can a broker pay for a better score?
No. Brokers pay us when you open an account through our links, at no extra cost to you, but no broker can buy a score. A formula calculates every score from the data.
How do we use AI?
Our team does the work on this page. We choose the data, write the rules every value is checked against and the score formula, test the brokers with live accounts and decide what we publish.
We use AI tools that we run ourselves to help us keep this data and our 28 editions up to date.
What does our method not do?
- It is not investment advice. Our scores compare brokers. They do not tell you what to trade or invest in.
- Our database comes from official sources, not from tests. The tests in our reviews measure the quality of trading at the broker's European company.
- A broker can change its conditions at any time. Before you open an account, read the broker's own documents and its risk warning.
Who does this work?

Filippo Ucchino, Co-Founder, CEO and Editor-in-Chief of InvestinGoal, designed the way we score brokers.

Luca Puddu, Broker Expert and Managing Editor, checks broker data with the brokers.