Scores, winners and data below compare these brokers as CFD/FX brokers (leveraged trading on forex, indices, commodities and crypto), using the data of IC Markets' Cyprus entity and XTB's Cyprus entity. Scores, winners and data below compare these brokers as stock brokers (real shares and ETFs you own outright), using the data of IC Markets' Cyprus entity and XTB's Cyprus entity.
IC Markets
72.52% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.
XTB
77% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.
Best for
What we compare A comparison of the kinds of traders IC Markets and XTB are best suited to, based on what each one actually offers in .IC Markets is better than XTB for professional traders and algo traders, while XTB is better for long-term investors. Scalpers, swing traders and news traders can choose either IC Markets or XTB.
| Overall score | IC Markets 87 Best not offered | XTB 77 -10 77 |
|---|---|---|
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for trading within the day. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for investing over years. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for professional traders. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for those who trade large volumes. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for very short trades. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for trades held days or weeks. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for trading around news events. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for automated strategies. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for trading shares and ETFs. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for trading cryptocurrencies. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for trading futures. | ||
| Whether we rate this broker a good fit for trading options. |
Regulation
What we compare A comparison between the financial authorities that supervise IC Markets and the ones that supervise XTB.IC Markets and XTB are both regulated by top-tier authorities, IC Markets by CySEC and ASIC (Australia) and XTB by CySEC, KNF and the FCA (United Kingdom).
| Section score | IC Markets 100 not offered | XTB 100 100 |
|---|---|---|
| Tier-1 regulators | ||
| Whether the broker holds a licence from a country that follows the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), the financial regulator of the European Union. | CySEC (Cyprus) | CySEC (Cyprus) |
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), the financial regulator of the United Kingdom. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), the financial regulator of Australia. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the financial regulator of the United States. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the National Futures Association (NFA), the financial regulator of the United States. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the financial regulator of the United States. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO), the financial regulator of Canada, formerly IIROC (Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada). | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS), the financial regulator of Singapore. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC), the financial regulator of Hong Kong. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Japan Financial Services Agency (JFSA), the financial regulator of Japan. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA), the financial regulator of Switzerland. | ||
| Tier-2 regulators | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Financial Markets Authority (FMA), the financial regulator of New Zealand. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Central Bank of Russia (CBR), the financial regulator of Russia. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA), the financial regulator of South Africa. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA), the financial regulator of Dubai. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC), the financial regulator of China. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Israel Securities Authority (ISA), the financial regulator of Israel. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Labuan Financial Services Authority (LFSA), the financial regulator of Malaysia. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Jordan Securities Commission (JSC), the financial regulator of Jordan. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Capital Markets Authority (CMA), the financial regulator of Kenya. | ||
| Tier-3 regulators | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Financial Services Authority (FSA), the financial regulator of the Seychelles. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Maldives Monetary Authority (MMA), the financial regulator of the Maldives. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Securities Commission of The Bahamas (SCB), the financial regulator of the Bahamas. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Financial Services Commission (FSC), the financial regulator of Mauritius. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Vanuatu Financial Services Commission (VFSC), the financial regulator of Vanuatu. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Financial Services Commission (FSC), the financial regulator of Belize. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (CIMA), the financial regulator of the Cayman Islands. | ||
| Whether the broker is registered with the Financial Services Authority (FSA) of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Financial Services Regulatory Commission (FSRC), the financial regulator of St. Kitts & Nevis. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Bermuda Monetary Authority (BMA), the financial regulator of Bermuda. | ||
| Whether the broker is regulated by the Financial Services Commission (FSC) of the British Virgin Islands. | ||
| Whether or not the broker has a deal with a private and independent EDR entity. | ||
Safety
What we compare A comparison of the tools and services that IC Markets and XTB have in place to protect your money in .IC Markets and XTB both offer segregated client funds and an investor compensation scheme.
| Section score | IC Markets 78 -8 not offered | XTB 86 Best 86 |
|---|---|---|
| Company info | ||
| Whether the company's shares are traded on a stock exchange. | ||
| Whether the broker holds a banking licence. | ||
| The year the company was founded. | 2007 | 2004 |
| The group that owns the broker. | International Capital Markets Pty Ltd | XTB S.A. |
| The person currently running the company. | Andrew Budzinski | Omar Arnaout |
| Money safety | ||
| Whether the broker keeps client money in accounts separate from its own. | ||
| Whether the broker offers two-factor authentication on your account. | ||
| Whether the broker is covered by a public scheme that repays clients if it fails. | ||
| Whether the broker adds private cover on top of the public scheme. | ||
| The bank(s) where client money is deposited. | Eurobank | N/A |
| Brand power | ||
| How many clients the broker reports having worldwide. | 1,600,000 | |
| The annual revenue the company reports. | USD 260,000,000 | |
| Estimated monthly visits to the broker's website from search. | 2.2M monthly visits | |
Costs
What we compare A comparison of what it costs to trade with IC Markets and with XTB in , both on each trade and on holding the account.IC Markets is better than XTB for CFD/FX costs, given that IC Markets is cheaper on EUR/USD, at 7.8 USD per lot (against XTB's 10.6 USD), has tighter S&P 500 CFD spreads, at 0.36 points (against XTB's 0.59 points), and has tighter gold CFD spreads, at 0.08 USD (against XTB's 0.89 USD). Neither IC Markets nor XTB charges account maintenance fees or deposit fees.
XTB and IC Markets cannot be compared for real stock costs, because XTB is a broker offering both CFDs and stocks while IC Markets is a CFD broker.
| Section score | IC Markets 65 Best not offered | XTB 53 -12 82 |
|---|---|---|
| Broker fees | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee to fund your account. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee when you withdraw your money. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee when you keep a leveraged position open overnight. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee if you leave the account unused. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee when a transaction involves a different currency than the one in your account. | ||
| Whether the broker lowers spreads or commissions for high-volume traders. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee to get real market data. | ||
| Whether the broker withholds tax on the dividends you receive. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee to open the account. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee to keep the account open. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee to manage a portfolio for you. | ||
| Fees on CFDs | ||
| The commission charged on one standard forex lot. | USD 7 | Free |
| The typical EUR/USD spread when it’s "variable" or "floating". | ||
| The typical raw EUR/USD spread, charged on Raw, ECN or STP (Straight Through Processing) accounts, the ones that pass your order to the market without a dealing desk in between. | ||
| The typical EUR/USD spread when it’s "fixed". | ||
| Our estimate of the total cost of one standard EUR/USD lot, spread and commission together. | USD 7.8 | USD 10.6 |
| The cost of trading the S&P 500 index as a CFD. | 0.36 points | 0.59 points |
| The cost of trading gold as a CFD (Contract for Difference), a contract that follows the price without owning the asset. | USD 0.08 | USD 0.89 |
| What you pay to trade bitcoin as a CFD (Contract for Difference), a contract that follows the price without owning the coin. | USD 6.46 | USD 205.25 |
| What you pay to trade US shares as CFDs (Contracts for Difference), contracts that follow the price without owning the shares. | USD 0.02 | Free |
| Fees on stocks | ||
| How the broker charges you on stocks, with a commission per trade, a percentage of the amount, a spread on the price, or nothing at all. | Commission, Percentage | Free, Percentage |
| What you pay to buy or sell US shares you actually own. | Free | |
| What you pay to buy or sell ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds) you actually own. | Free | |
| Whether the broker charges a fee to manage the account for you. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee for the connection to the trading venue. | ||
| Fees on futures | ||
| The commission charged on one futures contract. | Free | |
| Whether the broker charges a fee to use the futures platform. | ||
| Fees on options | ||
| The commission charged on one options contract. | Free | |
| Whether the broker charges a fee on options tied to a scheduled event. | ||
| Fees on savings plans | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee to open an IRA (Individual Retirement Account), the American tax-advantaged retirement account. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a yearly fee to keep an IRA (Individual Retirement Account) open, the American tax-advantaged retirement account. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a fee to open a 401(k) retirement account. | ||
| Whether the broker charges a yearly fee to keep a 401(k) open. | ||
Available markets
What we compare A comparison of the markets and products you can trade with IC Markets and with XTB in , and of how many instruments each one gives access to.IC Markets and XTB are close on CFD/FX markets. Both IC Markets and XTB offer CFDs on commodities, crypto, ETFs, forex, indices and stocks. XTB goes a step further, as it gives access to 5,200 tradable symbols (against IC Markets' 2,850), and lets you own ETFs and stocks outright.
Only XTB can be assessed for real stock markets, since IC Markets is a CFD broker and does not offer real stocks.
| Section score | IC Markets 75 not offered | XTB 75 30 |
|---|---|---|
| The total number of instruments the broker lists across all markets. | 2,850 | 5,200 |
| Whether the broker offers currency pairs. | ||
| Whether the broker offers stock market indices. | ||
| Whether the broker offers commodities such as oil or gold. | ||
| Whether the broker offers shares. | ||
| Whether the broker offers ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds), funds that track a basket of assets and trade like a single share. | ||
| Whether the broker offers cryptocurrencies. | ||
| Whether the broker offers bonds. | ||
| Whether the broker offers interest rate products. | ||
| Whether the broker offers ready-made portfolios you can invest in with one click. | ||
| Which markets you can trade as CFDs. | Commodities, Crypto, ETF, Forex, Indices, Stocks | Commodities, Crypto, ETF, Forex, Indices, Stocks |
| Which markets you can trade as futures. | ||
| Which markets you can trade as options. | ||
| Which assets you can buy outright and own, rather than only trade on their price. | ETF, Stocks |
Platform
What we compare A comparison of the trading platforms that IC Markets and XTB make available to their clients in .IC Markets is better than XTB for platforms, because IC Markets offers cTrader, MetaTrader 5 and MetaTrader 4, which XTB does not. Both IC Markets and XTB offer one-click trading and real-time pricing.
IC Markets does not offer real stocks, being a CFD broker, so XTB and IC Markets cannot be compared for platforms.
| Section score | IC Markets 89 Best not offered | XTB 75 -14 75 |
|---|---|---|
| Whether the broker has a trading platform of its own. | ||
| Whether the broker offers MetaTrader 4. | ||
| Whether the broker offers MetaTrader 5. | ||
| Whether the broker offers cTrader. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you follow and discuss trades with other traders. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you copy another trader's positions automatically. | ||
| Whether the broker connects to ZuluTrade for copy trading. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you trade through TradingView charts. | ||
| Whether the broker connects to DupliTrade for copy trading. | ||
| Whether the broker connects to Mirror Trader for copy trading. | ||
| Whether the broker offers NinjaTrader. | ||
| Whether the broker includes Autochartist, the tool that flags chart patterns. | ||
| Whether the broker gives you live prices, without a delay. | ||
| Whether the broker quotes prices to five decimals, for finer spreads. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you open a position with a single click. |
Mobile
What we compare A comparison of the mobile apps of IC Markets and XTB in , and of what each one lets you do from your phone.IC Markets is better than XTB for mobile trading, since IC Markets offers the cTrader app, the MetaTrader 5 app and the MetaTrader 4 app, which XTB does not. Both IC Markets and XTB offer a proprietary mobile app and mobile price alerts.
IC Markets does not offer real stocks, being a CFD broker, so XTB and IC Markets cannot be compared for mobile trading.
| Section score | IC Markets 93 Best not offered | XTB 67 -26 67 |
|---|---|---|
| Whether the broker has a trading app of its own. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you follow other traders from the app. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you copy other traders from the app. | ||
| Whether the broker supports the MetaTrader 4 app. | ||
| Whether the broker supports the MetaTrader 5 app. | ||
| Whether the broker supports the cTrader app. | ||
| Whether the broker sends trade suggestions to the app. | ||
| Whether the broker warns you from the app when a price is reached. | ||
| Whether the broker puts technical indicators on the charts in the app. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you draw on the charts from the app. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you keep your list of markets in the app. | ||
| Whether the broker has an app for smartwatches. |
Trading features
What we compare A comparison of the trading tools and strategies that IC Markets and XTB allow on their platforms in .IC Markets is better than XTB for CFD/FX trading features, given that IC Markets executes orders faster, within 66 ms (against XTB's 440 ms), offers tier-1 liquidity providers, which XTB does not, and allows for automated trading. Both IC Markets and XTB offer negative balance protection and trailing stops.
XTB and IC Markets cannot be compared for real stock trading features, because XTB is a broker offering both CFDs and stocks while IC Markets is a CFD broker.
| Section score | IC Markets 93 Best not offered | XTB 67 -26 76 |
|---|---|---|
| Trade execution | ||
| Agency (acts like a market maker, taking the opposite side of your trades), NDD (No Dealing Desk approach, meaning it doesn’t intervene in your trades), Hybrid (may act like an Agency or NDD broker depending on the situation). | NDD | NDD |
| How long the broker takes to fill an order, as it reports. | 66 ms | 440 ms |
| How often you get filled at a worse price than the one you asked for. | 28.05% | |
| How often the broker comes back with a different price instead of filling. | ||
| Whether the broker sources its prices from top-tier banks. | ||
| Whether the broker uses PFOF (Payment For Order Flow), selling your orders to a third party instead of sending them straight to the market. | ||
| Leverage | ||
| The highest leverage allowed on the main FX (foreign exchange) pairs, the most traded currency pairs. | 30:1About this value. This is the major fx pairs leverage at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: 30:1 (Australia), 5000:1 (other accepted countries). | 30:1 |
| The highest leverage allowed on minor and exotic FX (foreign exchange) pairs. | 20:1About this value. This is the minor/exotic fx pairs leverage at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: 20:1 (Australia), 5000:1 (other accepted countries). | 20:1 |
| The highest leverage allowed on the main stock indices. | 20:1About this value. This is the major indices leverage at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: 20:1 (Australia), 200:1 (other accepted countries). | 20:1 |
| The highest leverage allowed on the smaller stock indices. | 10:1About this value. This is the minor indices leverage at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: 10:1 (Australia), 200:1 (other accepted countries). | 10:1 |
| The highest leverage allowed on gold. | 20:1About this value. This is the gold leverage at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: 20:1 (Australia), 2000:1 (other accepted countries). | 20:1 |
| The highest leverage allowed on commodities other than gold. | 10:1About this value. This is the commodities leverage at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: 10:1 (Australia), 1000:1 (other accepted countries). | 10:1 |
| The highest leverage allowed on single shares. | 5:1About this value. This is the equities leverage at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: 5:1 (Australia), 20:1 (other accepted countries). | 5:1 |
| The highest leverage allowed on cryptocurrencies. | 2:1About this value. This is the cryptocurrency leverage at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: 2:1 (Australia), 500:1 (other accepted countries). | 2:1 |
| Risk management | ||
| Whether the broker lets you set a price at which a losing trade closes on its own. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you set a price at which a winning trade closes on its own. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you order at a price of your choosing, instead of the current one. | ||
| Whether the broker lets your stop follow the price as the trade moves in your favour. | ||
| Whether the broker asks you for more money before it starts closing your positions. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you place OCO (One Cancels the Other) orders, two orders where filling one cancels the other. | ||
| Whether the broker guarantees your stop price even when the market gaps. | ||
| Whether the broker stops you from losing more than the money in your account. | ||
| The smallest position you can open on FX (foreign exchange), the currency market. | 0.01 lots | 0.01 lots |
| The smallest position you can open on shares. | USD 0 | USD 0 |
| Whether the broker lets you buy part of a share instead of a whole one. | ||
| Trading compliance | ||
| Whether the broker allows trading in and out within seconds. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you hold a buy and a sell on the same market at once. | ||
| Whether the broker allows software to place trades for you. | ||
| Whether the broker allows Expert Advisors, the automated programs of MetaTrader. | ||
| Whether the broker allows HFT (High-Frequency Trading), placing very large numbers of orders in fractions of a second. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you use a VPS (Virtual Private Server), an always-on remote computer that keeps your strategy running. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an API (Application Programming Interface), so your own software can place trades directly. | ||
| Whether the broker allows its prices to be taken for use elsewhere. | ||
| Whether the FIFO (First In, First Out) rule applies, so the first position you open must be the first you close. | ||
Account types
What we compare A comparison of the kinds of account you can open at IC Markets and at XTB in , and of who each one is meant for.IC Markets is better than XTB for CFD/FX account types, since IC Markets offers a managed account, an ECN account and a copy trading account, which XTB does not. Both IC Markets and XTB offer a demo account and a professional traders account.
Only XTB can be assessed for real stock account types, since IC Markets is a CFD broker and does not offer real stocks.
| Section score | IC Markets 79 Best not offered | XTB 47 -32 58 |
|---|---|---|
| Whether the broker offers a practice account with virtual money. | ||
| Whether the broker leaves the practice account open with no time limit. | ||
| Whether the broker offers a standard account, where the spread is the main cost. | ||
| Whether the broker offers a micro account, trading in lots ten times smaller than standard. | ||
| Whether the broker offers a cent account, where the balance is counted in cents. | ||
| Whether the broker offers a nano account, for the smallest position sizes. | ||
| Whether the broker offers a raw account, with near-zero spreads and a separate commission. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an ECN (Electronic Communication Network) account, which sends your order straight to the market network. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account with no overnight interest. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account that follows Islamic finance rules. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account for traders who qualify as professional. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account where the spread stays fixed. | ||
| Whether the broker offers spread betting, where the law allows it. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account set up to copy other traders. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account in a company's name. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account someone else trades for you. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account for buying shares you own. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account where you can invest with borrowed money. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account for putting money aside with a tax advantage. | ||
| Whether the broker offers an account for retirement saving. |
Account opening
What we compare A comparison of what it takes to open and fund an account with IC Markets and with XTB in .IC Markets is better than XTB for account opening, as IC Markets offers 10 account base currencies (against XTB's 3), supports 3 e-wallets (against XTB's 2), and pays out withdrawals faster, within 1 day (against XTB's 3 days). That said, XTB asks for no minimum deposit at all (against IC Markets' 200 USD).
There is no like-for-like comparison for account opening, as IC Markets is a CFD broker and does not offer real stocks.
| Section score | IC Markets 85 Best not offered | XTB 75 -10 75 |
|---|---|---|
| The smallest amount you need to open the account. | USD 200About this value. This is the minimum deposit at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). At IC Markets' other companies: USD 200 (Australia), USD 0 (other accepted countries). | USD 0 |
| The smallest amount you can take out at a time. | USD 0 | USD 0 |
| Whether the broker lets you fund the account by bank transfer. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you fund the account with a credit card. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you fund the account with a debit card. | ||
| The electronic wallets you can use, such as PayPal or Skrill. | PayPal, Neteller, Skrill | PayPal, SkrillAbout this value. This is the ewallets at XTB Limited (Cyprus) (CySEC). It is different at XTB's companies in the EU. |
| Whether the broker accepts a payment method common in your country. | ||
| The currencies your account can be held in. | AUD, CAD, CHF, EUR, GBP, HKD, JPY, NZD, SGD, USDAbout this value. This is the account base currencies at IC Markets (EU) Ltd (CySEC). It is different at IC Markets' companies in Australia. | EUR, HUF, USDAbout this value. This is the account base currencies at XTB Limited (Cyprus) (CySEC). It is different at XTB's companies in the UK, the UAE and the EU. |
| How long your money takes to reach the account. | Instant | Instant |
| How long your money takes to come back to you. | up to 1 business days | up to 3 business days |
| Whether the broker offers a bonus when you sign up or deposit. |
Customer care
What we compare A comparison of the customer support of IC Markets and XTB in , in how it can be reached and how fast it answers.IC Markets is better than XTB for customer care, given that IC Markets offers customer support in 17 languages (against XTB's 10), has a website in 17 languages (against XTB's 14), and offers a dedicated account manager, which XTB does not. Both IC Markets and XTB offer phone support and live chat.
XTB and IC Markets cannot be set side by side for customer care, as IC Markets is a CFD broker and does not offer real stocks, unlike XTB.
| Section score | IC Markets 87 Best not offered | XTB 62 -25 62 |
|---|---|---|
| How many languages the broker covers in total. | 17 | 14 |
| The languages the website is available in. | Arabic, Bulgarian, Czech, German, English, French, Croatian, Indonesian, Italian, Korean, Malay, Portuguese, Russian, Spanish, Thai, Vietnamese, Chinese | Arabic, Czech, German, English, French, Hungarian, Italian, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Slovenian, Spanish, Turkish, Chinese |
| Whether the broker has the website in English. | ||
| The languages you can get help in. | Arabic, Bulgarian, Czech, German, English, French, Croatian, Indonesian, Italian, Korean, Malay, Portuguese, Russian, Spanish, Thai, Vietnamese, Chinese | Arabic, Greek, English, French, Italian, Russian, Spanish, Thai, Turkish, Chinese |
| Whether the broker gives you help in English. | ||
| Whether the broker calls you back on request. | ||
| Whether the broker gives you help by email. | ||
| Whether the broker gives you help by phone. | ||
| Whether the broker gives you help by chat, while you wait. | ||
| Whether the broker answers some clients first. | ||
| Whether the broker gives you one person who follows your account. | ||
| Whether the broker pays you interest on the cash sitting in your account. | ||
| Whether the broker lends out your shares and shares the earnings with you. | ||
| Whether the broker passes dividends and other payouts on to you. | ||
| Whether the broker holds back the tax on your behalf. | ||
| Whether the broker helps you with your tax paperwork. |
Learning
What we compare A comparison of the educational material that IC Markets and XTB provide to their clients in .IC Markets is better than XTB for learning, because IC Markets offers professional reports, which XTB does not. IC Markets and XTB both offer education for advanced traders and webinars.
There is no like-for-like comparison for learning, as IC Markets is a CFD broker and does not offer real stocks.
| Section score | IC Markets 100 Best not offered | XTB 88 -12 88 |
|---|---|---|
| Education | ||
| Whether the broker has a section dedicated to learning. | ||
| Whether the broker has material that starts from the basics. | ||
| Whether the broker has material for traders who already know the basics. | ||
| Whether the broker runs live online sessions. | ||
| Whether the broker has step-by-step guides. | ||
| Whether the broker explains the terms it uses. | ||
| Research | ||
| Whether the broker shows the scheduled events that move the markets. | ||
| Whether the broker shows how its other clients are positioned. | ||
| Whether the broker comments on the markets every day. | ||
| Whether the broker suggests trades to consider. | ||
| Whether the broker publishes market news on social media. | ||
| Whether the broker gives you the kind of research written for professionals. | ||
| Whether the broker lets you keep a list of the markets you follow. | ||
72.52% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.
IC Markets vs XTB: which one should you choose?
CFD/FX Choose IC Markets if you want a CFD and forex broker for automated trading with low trading costs and cTrader.
72.52% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.
CFD/FX Choose XTB if you want an online CFD broker with a proprietary trading platform, a wide choice of markets and no minimum deposit.
Stocks Choose XTB if you want a share dealing service with commission-free US stocks and a wide choice of markets.
77% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider.
Other popular comparisons
Below are other head-to-head comparisons that include IC Markets or XTB, each scored with the same data and method as this page.